Reddit is a great platform for bringing people together under a common topic, whether it is news, gaming or bizarrely specific subreddits (r/birdswitharms anyone…?) – it really does have something for every interest. It can also be a great source of news and insights for the retro gaming community. Sadly, the days of the traditional bulletin boards are dying, and Reddit seems to be the place to be to find the meta of all BBs in one place.
So, let’s have a look at the biggest retro gaming communities in the world of Reddit, as ranked by member numbers, plus the hottest post of all time for each. For the record, I am only considering up to generation 5 for this list.
Before we begin, if you are a fan of retro gaming – I implore you to check out our free weekly retro gaming newsletter, delivered to your inbox every Monday and packed with all of the latest retro gaming news.
10. The Atari 2600 R/Atari2600 @12k Subs
Some might call this the console that started putting gaming into the mainstream, others might blame it on the video game crash of 1983. Whatever it means to you, it is a crucial part of gaming history and stakes a big claim for igniting the mainstream of video games. Coming in at 12k subs at the time of writing, it squeezes into the top 10. If you collect Atari 2600 games, then check out our RetroShell cases, which are the finest protection you can get. And here is its top post ever.
I’m 19 I should be into girls or underage drinking or something
byu/TheSwoodening inAtari2600
9. The SEGA CD /r/SEGACD @12k Subs
A bold attempt by SEGA to leap into the future of gaming, the SEGA CD (or Mega-CD as us Europeans know it as) added CD-ROM capabilities to the Genesis (Megadrive), bringing full-motion video (FMV) and enhanced audio to the forefront. While it didn’t see massive success, it’s still remembered fondly for cult classics like Sonic CD and Night Trap. At 12k subs, it ties with its retro sibling, the Neo Geo, and makes the top 10 by a thread. And here’s its top post ever.
Two months and two Model 1s later, I have a working Sega CD!
byu/trustanchor inSegaCD
8. The Neo Geo R/NeoGeo @12k Subs
The Neo Geo was the ultimate arcade experience at home, famous for its jaw-dropping price and unmatched graphical fidelity for its time. Known for timeless fighting games like Samurai Shodown and King of Fighters, it’s a dream machine for retro enthusiasts. Its community of 12k members holds strong, celebrating this powerhouse console. And here’s its top post ever.
Hello from France.
byu/Dry-Primary6128 inneogeo
7. Sega Saturn /r/SegaSaturn @35k Subs
The Sega Saturn, a misunderstood gem of the 32-bit era, struggled against stiff competition but delivered a library of innovative and experimental games like Nights into Dreams and Panzer Dragoon Saga. With 35k subs, the Saturn fanbase continues to champion its unique place in gaming history. Here you have its top post.
$30 garage sale haul
byu/cafink inSegaSaturn
6. Sega Genesis /r/SegaGenesis @48k (or 57.4k) Subs
The Sega Genesis (or Mega Drive for some) was Sega’s bold challenge to Nintendo’s dominance, delivering classics like Sonic the Hedgehog and Streets of Rage. Its legendary “blast processing” marketing and edgy attitude cemented its legacy. At 48k subs, it comfortably secures a spot in the retro console pantheon – if we include the r/Megadrive which has 9.6k then you have 57.4k members. Here is the top post.
I drew a Genesis exploded view
byu/Poire_ inSEGAGENESIS
5. PSX /r/PSX @105k Subs
Sony’s PlayStation (PSX) broke new ground in gaming with its embrace of 3D graphics, a massive game library, and unforgettable titles like Final Fantasy VII and Metal Gear Solid. At 105k subs, the PSX community proves that this revolutionary console still holds a special place in gamers’ hearts. And here’s its top post ever.
Posts from the psx
community on Reddit
4. Nintendo NES /r/NES @108k Subs
The Nintendo Entertainment System (NES) revived the gaming industry after the crash of 1983, introducing iconic franchises like Super Mario Bros. and The Legend of Zelda. With 108k subs, it remains a cornerstone of retro gaming nostalgia. If you are a NES game collector, we have a RetroShell to help you keep your treasures in the best condition. And here’s its top post ever, with an amazing title.
Hello dark nes my old friend
by innes
3. Nintendo SNES /r/SNES @154k Subs
The Super Nintendo Entertainment System (SNES) took 16-bit gaming to new heights with unforgettable masterpieces like Super Metroid and Chrono Trigger. At 154k subs, the SNES fanbase is as vibrant as ever, celebrating the pinnacle of 2D gaming. If you have some SNES games, we have a RetroShell to help you keep it preserved in style. Want to know the top post, we have this amazing collection.
Today I finished my snes set 720/720
byu/blackandbluebolts insnes
2. Nintendo 64 /r/N64 @205k Subs
The Nintendo 64 brought 3D gaming to the masses with groundbreaking titles like Super Mario 64 and The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. At 205k subs, it’s clear this console still holds a massive place in gamers’ hearts. Guess what, we also have a RetroShell for this gaming legend. Want to know the top post, we have this amazing collection.
My orthodontist’s office has a n64 kiosk
byu/AudioVid3o inn64
1. 1. Game Boy /r/GameBoy @227k Subs
The Game Boy redefined gaming on the go with its incredible portability and a library led by Tetris and Pokémon Red and Blue. At a staggering 227k subs, it sits proudly atop the list, proving its enduring appeal among retro gaming fans (RetroShell coming very soon). Here is the top post, and it’s a mighty fine achievement (but now do this with boxes 😂).
After 10 years I’ve completed the US original GameBoy cartridge set!
byu/popfonics inGameboy
So there you have it, the OG Game Boy tops the chart, not really a surprise given its amazing catalogue and lifespan (and also I guess it is a catchall for multiple systems). Thanks very much for reading, if you love retro news, you can also follow us on X, or join the r/Retroshell sub.